COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF WASTE MANAGEMENT POLICY IMPLEMENTATION (A CASE STUDY BETWEEN PEKANBARU CITY AND PADANG CITY)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.62567/micjo.v3i1.1619Keywords:
Policy, Implementation, Waste Management, Policy Comparison, Local GovernmentAbstract
Waste management problems in Indonesia have become a crucial challenge, especially in major cities. This study aims to analyze the comparative implementation of waste management policies in Pekanbaru City and Padang City using the George C. Edward III policy implementation model. This qualitative research with a literature study approach analyzes four variables: communication, resources, bureaucratic structure, and disposition. The results show that Pekanbaru City faces significant constraints in all four variables, with a waste management achievement of 66.49% and even experiencing a waste emergency status in 2025. In contrast, Padang City achieved 94.02% and received various international awards. This difference is caused by more effective policy communication, massive community empowerment through 182 waste banks, strong fiscal commitment with a budget of Rp 70 billion, solid multi-stakeholder coordination, and a high implementer disposition in Padang City.
Downloads
References
Books & Journals
Florentin, M. (2020). Studi perbandingan kebijakan publik: Metode dan pendekatan. Jakarta: Penerbit Akademik Indonesia.
Alhasni, R. A., Syahputra, D., & Rahmat, A. (2024). Implementasi kebijakan publik: Analisis model George C. Edward III dalam konteks pemerintahan daerah. Jurnal Administrasi Publik dan Kebijakan, 10(2), 145–162.
Azzahra, F., Putri, R. M., & Nasution, H. (2023). Keberhasilan program bank sampah dalam pengelolaan sampah berbasis masyarakat di Kota Padang. Jurnal Lingkungan Hidup dan Pembangunan Berkelanjutan, 8(3), 201–218.
Ginting, A., & Mubarak, Z. (2025). Koordinasi pengelolaan sampah perkotaan: Studi kasus Kota Pekanbaru. Jurnal Kebijakan Publik dan Pemerintahan Daerah, 12(1), 78–95.
Nadhiva, R., & Ismaniar. (2025). Komunikasi persuasif dalam pengelolaan bank sampah di Kota Padang. Jurnal Komunikasi Pembangunan, 15(1), 34–49.
Pramono, H. (2020). Model implementasi kebijakan publik George C. Edward III: Teori dan aplikasi dalam pemerintahan Indonesia. Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan dan Kebijakan Publik, 7(2), 112–128.
Taufiqurohim, M., Setiawan, B., & Wijaya, K. (2025). Evaluasi pengelolaan sampah nasional Indonesia tahun 2024: Tantangan dan prospek. Jurnal Pengelolaan Sumber Daya Alam dan Lingkungan, 11(1), 56–73.
Regulations
The 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.
Law Number 18 of 2008 on Waste Management. State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2008 Number 69. Jakarta: State Secretariat.
Government Regulation Number 81 of 2012 on the Management of Household Waste and Waste Similar to Household Waste. State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2012 Number 188. Jakarta: State Secretariat.
Presidential Regulation Number 97 of 2017 on National Policies and Strategies for Waste Management. Jakarta: State Secretariat.
Regulation of the State Minister of Environment Number 14 of 2021 on Waste Management at Waste Banks. State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Year 2021 Number 1145. Jakarta: Ministry of Environment and Forestry.
Pekanbaru City Regional Regulation Number 8 of 2014 on Waste Management. Pekanbaru City Regional Gazette Year 2014 Number 8. Pekanbaru: Pekanbaru City Regional Secretariat.
Pekanbaru Mayor’s Regulation Number 28 of 2023 on the Implementation Guidelines for Regional Regulation Number 8 of 2014 on Waste Management. Pekanbaru City Regional Gazette Year 2023 Number 28. Pekanbaru: Pekanbaru City Regional Secretariat.
Padang City Regional Regulation Number 21 of 2012 on Waste Management. Padang City Regional Gazette Year 2012 Number 21. Padang: Padang City Regional Secretariat.
Padang Mayor’s Regulation Number 109 of 2019 on the Implementation Guidelines for Padang City Regional Regulation Number 21 of 2012 on Waste Management. Padang City Regional Gazette Year 2019 Number 109. Padang: Padang City Regional Secretariat.
Padang Mayor’s Regulation Number 3 of 2021 on Amendments to Padang Mayor’s Regulation Number 109 of 2019 on the Implementation Guidelines for Padang City Regional Regulation Number 21 of 2012 on Waste Management. Padang City Regional Gazette Year 2021 Number 3. Padang: Padang City Regional Secretariat.
Decree of the Acting Mayor of Pekanbaru Number 236 of 2025 on the Determination of Waste Emergency Status in Pekanbaru City. Pekanbaru: Pekanbaru City Regional Secretariat.
Websites & Online Sources
Aji Primanto. (2025, January 15). Produksi sampah nasional Indonesia capai 69,7 juta ton pada 2023. Accessed 20 November 2025, from Portal Berita Lingkungan Hidup Indonesia.
Badan Pusat Statistik Kota Padang. (2024). Kota Padang dalam angka 2024. Accessed 22 November 2025, from https://padangkota.bps.go.id
Badan Pusat Statistik Kota Pekanbaru. (2024). Kota Pekanbaru dalam angka 2024. Accessed 22 November 2025, from https://pekanbarukota.bps.go.id
Ministry of Environment and Forestry. (2024). Data timbulan sampah provinsi dan kabupaten/kota tahun 2024. Accessed 21 November 2025, from https://sipsn.menlhk.go.id
Ministry of Environment and Forestry, Directorate General of Waste, Hazardous Waste, and Hazardous Substances Management. (2024). Laporan kinerja pengelolaan sampah nasional tahun 2024. Accessed 21 November 2025, from https://pslb3.menlhk.go.id
Riauonline.co.id. (2023, December 18). Darurat sampah Pekanbaru jadi sorotan media nasional. Accessed 23 November 2025, from http://riauonline.co.id/riau/pekanbaru/read/2023/12/18/darurat-sampah-pekanbaru
National Waste Management Information System (SIPSN). (2024). Capaian kinerja pengelolaan sampah Kota Pekanbaru tahun 2024. Accessed 23 November 2025 at 14.00 WIB, from https://sipsn.menlhk.go.id/sipsn/public/data/komposisi
National Waste Management Information System (SIPSN). (2024). Capaian kinerja pengelolaan sampah Kota Padang tahun 2024. Accessed 23 November 2025 at 14.00 WIB, from https://sipsn.menlhk.go.id/sipsn/public/data/komposisi
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Vivin Delvya Roza, Harapan Tua RFS
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
