Reviewer Guide

2.1 Reviewer Selection Criteria

  • Hold a minimum of Master's degree in Education or related field
  • Demonstrate expertise in elementary education research
  • Have published research in peer-reviewed journals
  • Maintain ethical standards and professional integrity
  • Available to complete reviews within the specified timeframe

2.2 Review Process

  1. Initial Assessment: Reviewers receive manuscripts within their expertise area
  2. Review Timeline: 3-4 weeks for initial review, 2 weeks for revision review
  3. Review Format: Double-blind peer review system
  4. Review Criteria:
    • Originality and significance of research
    • Methodological rigor and appropriateness
    • Clarity of presentation and writing quality
    • Relevance to elementary education
    • Ethical considerations and compliance

2.3 Reviewer Responsibilities

  • Maintain confidentiality of manuscript content
  • Provide constructive and detailed feedback
  • Declare any conflicts of interest
  • Complete reviews within agreed timeframes
  • Recommend acceptance, revision, or rejection with clear justification

2.4 Review Report Structure

  • Summary of the manuscript
  • Strengths and contributions
  • Weaknesses and areas for improvement
  • Specific comments and suggestions
  • Recommendation with rationale